‘Government must create jobs’: Taxpayer concerns spark fresh SASSA grant debate

South Africans are once again debating the future of SASSA social grants, with many raising concerns about who ultimately pays for them.

Comments on The South African’s Facebook page show a growing frustration with the country’s dependence on grants and the pressure these places on a limited pool of taxpayers.

Jobs over grants

Donovan Kay believes the answer to poverty lies in employment rather than handouts.

“Government must create jobs; that’s the only way to counteract poverty. SASSA grants come from taxpayers, and taxpayers are becoming fewer and fewer in this country,” Kay wrote.

His comment reflects a concern many economists share. South Africa has one of the highest unemployment rates in the world, which means fewer people earn enough to pay income tax while more people rely on state support. Every grant payment, from the Older Persons Grant to the Social Relief of Distress (SRD) grant, draws from the national budget funded largely by individual and corporate taxpayers.

A shrinking tax base under pressure

Kay’s point touches on a long-running fiscal debate. When businesses close, skilled workers emigrate or jobs disappear, the tax base narrows. At the same time, demand for social assistance continues to rise as households struggle with the cost of living.

This imbalance places Treasury in a difficult position. Cutting grants would push millions of vulnerable people deeper into poverty, while expanding them without economic growth increases the burden on those who already pay.

Julian Humphries shared a similar view, writing that “Everybody that works regardless of what they do must contribute in order for this to be possible.”

Where the conversation goes next

The debate highlights a broader question about South Africa’s economic direction. Grants remain a lifeline for pensioners, caregivers and unemployed adults, and for many households they are the only reliable income.

However, commenters such as Kay argue that long-term relief will only come once more South Africans find stable work. Job creation would not only reduce reliance on grants but also widen the pool of taxpayers who fund them.

Until then, the tension between protecting the vulnerable and protecting the public purse is likely to remain at the centre of conversations about SASSA and the country’s social safety net.

Win R2 000 in the South African SASSA grant survey

If you receive a SASSA grant and want to share your story, we want to hear from you.

Take part in our survey and stand a chance to win R2 000. Your responses help us tell the stories that matter.