Shadrack Sibiya bail hearing: Court hears threats, cover-up claims

A 25-minute audio recording sparked fresh controversy during former deputy national police commissioner Shadrack Sibiya’s bail hearing at the Randburg Magistrate’s Court on Tuesday, 13 October.

The recording captured businessman Serge Cabonge making allegations about his dealings with Sibiya, several prominent figures and an alleged criminal cover-up.

The court played the conversation between Cabonge and a man identified as Mr M, who has accused Sibiya of threatening him and his family.

Cabonge claimed he maintained close ties with Sibiya and implicated several individuals, including businessman Vusimuzi “Cat” Matlala, National Director of Public Prosecutions Shamila Batohi and businessman Hangwani Maumela.

He also alleged that Sibiya conducted several dealings through Sergeant Fannie Nkosi.

The claims have not been independently verified, and the recording does not establish wrongdoing by those named.

SIBIYA BAIL | The Randburg Magistrate's Court hears an audio clip in which businessman Serge Cabonge alleges that Shadrack Sibiya has close links to Shamila Batohi, Vusimuzi Matlala and Hangwani Maumela. Tune in to SABC News and SABC Plus. pic.twitter.com/0TbYlaQZV3

— SABC News (@SABCNews) October 13, 2026

COURT HEARS ALLEGATIONS OF CRIMINAL COVER-UP

In the recording, Cabonge described how he allegedly intervened in a police investigation following a road accident in Sandton.

He claimed that an individual linked to the Madlanga Commissionapproached him for assistance after the incident.

Cabonge alleged that he contacted someone who could access police records and established that an investigator he knew was handling the case.

He further claimed that the complainant later received instructions to withdraw the matter.

According to Cabonge, the same individual subsequently advised him to leave South Africa after witnesses mentioned his name during proceedings before the Madlanga Commission.

He alleged that he travelled abroad and remained outside the country for several months.

The recording did not establish the identity of the individual, and the court has not verified Cabonge’s allegations.

SIBIYA ACCUSED OF THREATENING WITNESS AND HIS FAMILY

The court also heard an affidavit from Mr M, who accused Sibiya of threatening him and his family.

Mr M claimed that Sibiya had previously warned him that he knew his family and could harm them.

He told the court that the alleged threats left him fearing for his safety.

“I know what General Sibiya is capable of,” he said.

The State raised concerns about possible witness intimidation as prosecutors continued opposing Sibiya’s release on bail.

Sibiya has denied the criminal allegations against him.

DEFENCE CHALLENGES AUDIO RECORDING

Sibiya’s defence sought to withdraw an audio recording that Mr M had submitted as part of his wife’s affidavit.

However, the State argued that the recording remained relevant to the bail proceedings.

Investigating officer Noah Kayandla also took the stand to confirm the origin of the recorded conversation between Cabonge and Mr M.

The court heard the recording before allowing Sibiya’s legal team to consult with him.

Sibiya faces criminal charges including rape, human trafficking and the sexual grooming of a minor.

The matter has been postponed to Wednesday, 14 October. Sibiya remains in custody.